As expected, the countdown to the final closing days of the homebuyer tax credit has brought on more debate. Should the government create more programs aimed at boosting home sales or just stay out of it and let the market correct itself?
Many of the programs that were created to help homeowners and home buyers have been utter failures. Sure, the tax credit boosted sales while it was in place. But even now that conditions arguably are better for buyers – record low interest rates and lower prices in many areas – home sales continue to slog in many cities.
Another program may or may not help home buyers or struggling homeowners. But what happens when it ends? With the home buyer tax credit, we saw an artificial boost to the market, followed by the inevitable fall in sales as the immediate incentive went away.
So what’s next? As I’ve said in this column before, it’s all in the jobs, really. If the government really wants to help housing and homeowners then we need to think about security, incomes that are in step with mortgage payments, and a confidence in the future.
With interest rates as low as they are and the opportunities that abound for buyers today, it only makes sense that the missing key here is stability in incomes. Tax credit or no tax credit, life goes on. The reasons for buying and selling real estate always withstand the test of time – through markets good and bad. It’s a roof over your family’s head. It’s pride in ownership.
The government might do better to focus on helping those families who feel stuck – the ones who are underwater on their mortgages. They want to be owners. They have the means to pay. But they feel caught up in the waves of the mortgage mess that inflated the values of homes when they happened to buy. Another tax credit is not going to help them continue to pay a mortgage on a house they know they can’t sell without a loss.
Let’s get to the root of the problem, which isn’t necessarily home prices or the pace of sales. The real problem is a lack of stability and a lack of economic security. That’s the glue that holds together American ownership.
