Even in a “normal” year (when someone actually finds one of those, please tell me), I am bombarded each spring with questions about real estate transactions and their implications on Federal and State income taxes.
In a year in which we’re experiencing continued economic hardships, and since many of those hardships relate directly to home sales and foreclosures, I’m getting far more than usual.
Right out of the blocks, I tell them that I’m not a tax professional and that any questions that they have ought to be directed to their accountants and financial advisors. That said, I like to do all I can to help folks out, so I answer questions where I am able.
One of the most frequent questions I hear — and the one whose answer seems somewhat out of reach — pertains to short sales.
“I sold my house this year, but it was a short sale. Can the IRS or my state tax the forgiven debt?”
The answer is, “Yes. Yes, they can.” A better question is, “Will they?”
With regard to the Federal Government, the answer is “no”. In a move meant to encourage homeowners to work out alternatives to foreclosure, the Federal Government has placed a moratorium on the taxation of forgiven mortgage debt through 2012.
Many states have followed suit, but there are a great many who have not. One of the states in which the question has yet to be answered is California, a state that has been hit harder than most in this period of crisis, and also one whose economic woes far exceed that of any other.
While it may sound unfair, forgiven debt has always been treated as income and, until the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 was enacted, that income could (and would) be taxable.
At the time of this writing, Governor Schwarzenegger had not made a decision with regard to the state collecting taxes on forgiven debts, but in a state that is as cash-starved as California, there is a strong possibility that he’ll have no choice but to do so.
If you sold your home last year and that sale was a short sale, there are heady tax implications attached to it. It is imperative that you consult with your accountant or financial advisor, so that you can adequately prepare to meet the tax man, should he come a’calling.




